Pennsylvania’s Sabrina Carpenter is reportedly on a break from boyfriend Barry Keoghan. The pop-phenom, who has a Netflix Christmas special debuting Friday, and Keoghan have gone quiet on social media, fueling speculation their year-long relationship is currently off.

Although neither have responded to the report, this isn’t the first time the pair’s relationship has been debated online. Back in August, Keoghan stirred the breakup pot further by leaving a comment on a video suggesting their love had fizzled out. The following month, Keoghan was back to publicly flirting with Carpenter.

While Sabrina Carpenter and Barry Keoghan were a relatively new couple, there are still plenty of fans (specially young people) who shipped them. Another tweet about the breakup highlighted how surprising it was, offering: